Hi
Andy,
When the Cubs are bringing
the flags to the front of the room on which side does the American flag
go?
Should the American
flag
lead and the pack flag follow?
When carried, should the flag be at an
angle to the bearer? (Art
Aigner, CM,
Greater
Niagara Frontier Council, NY)
If the Cubs are carrying the flags
single-file (one behind the other) then the American flag always leads. If the two carrying the
flags are side by side, then the American flag is always to its own
right, relative to the direction of travel.
This means that someone in the front of the room would see the American
flag on the left, facing him.
Side by side, when the flags reach the front of the room, the American
flag crosses in front of all other flags and is placed in the flag stand
that's to the audience's left but its own right, facing the audience. Single-file, the American
flag simply goes to the left, so it's facing the audience from its own
right.
Dear Andy:
Many years ago I
was the Scoutmaster
of the troop I grew up in.
After
having
served
on my district and council committees for about 15 years, I’ve elected
to return to my troop as an ASM. The current Scoutmaster's son will be
aging out soon and so
he (the Scoutmaster) is making rumblings that it’s time for him to step
down.
I’ve told
our Committee
Chair
that I’d be the new SM if no one
else steps
up.
When I was
Scoutmaster before,
I feel that I did a lot of things—like The Patrol Method—correctly
and
some
things maybe not so well—like
issuing
“edicts”
to get things accomplished and creating rules for advancement as well as
other things.
One rule I had was the “double-dinner
rule,” which
stipulated that a patrol couldn’t
use a dinner menu more
than once in
the regular Scouting
season (September through
June), my intent
being
to teach
menu planning
diversity;
but it came across as an
“edict.”
Currently, the
troop
committee is holding
board of review only
three times a year, with the further stipulation that no Scout can advance more than one rank at each
review,
regardless of the
rank
requirements he’s
completed, and I’d want to correct or adjust
this.
So,
if a Scoutmaster is a "mild supervisor," how does
he
insist on
following
BSA standards and policies without coming across as draconian or
dictatorial?
For instance, how would
I insist on the Patrol Method being used effectively
without seeming like it’s an “edict”? (Steve
Sassi,
Theodore Roosevelt Council, NY)
Let's start here: Who runs the
troop? If you said, "The Patrol Leaders
Council, led by the Senior Patrol Leader," you've got it right.
The Scoutmaster's in the background, guiding, mentoring, and coaching
the troop's youth leaders, primarily the SPL. So, my first suggestion
is for you, any ASMs, and the members of the committee to get out there
and take (or re-take) the training for your positions, including
Scoutmaster-specific and the Troop Committee Challenge. This is where you'll all learn
together such things as the unreasonableness of establishing "edicts
from on high" and how boards of review are conducted as often as
necessary on an as-needed basis, including back-to-back reviews for
Scouts who have completed all requirements for, let's say, Second Class
and
First Class, because one of the committee's most
important responsibilities is to encourage, not retard, advancement.
Menu" edicts"? Personally, I wouldn't
bother, because
Scouts get bored with same-old, same-old time after time and will make
menu changes all by themselves.
Plus, if you're truly using The Patrol Method, one patrol will start
cooking something new and the others will see this and ask themselves,
Hey, why can't
we
do something like that, next
time!"
Plus, when you and your ASM cook a gourmet
dinner for yourselves, your Scouts will spot this and take away some
good ideas... they may even ask, "How do you do that, on the trail?" This is how you guide...
By example
(Works
much better than barking orders!).
"Insisting" on The Patrol Method? Where's the "insisting" part?
The troop is merely the "shell" in which patrols operate. Without The
Patrol Method, you're simply not delivering Boy Scouting. Yes, you're
delivering
something,
but it's definitely not Boy Scouting.
So, if it's not, now, the troop needs to organize itself into standing
patrols that hang together, hike together, do meal-planning together,
and camp together on-site.
They also arrange their own transportation, have patrol flags,
wear patrol medallions, have regular patrol elections, and so forth.
Eliminate this essential element and you have a bunch o' boys in tan
shirts, but you don't have Boy Scouting.
Good decisions spring from experience; experience
comes from learning from our not-so-hot decisions.
Simple as that!
Hi Andy,
As a newly
“de-throned” Akela, I'm taking deep breaths and trying to
stay out of the way of my new Boy Scout son's
advancement.
OK, that's a little more melodramatic than reality, but I’m trying to
keep in mind Boy Scouts isn’t “Webelos 3.” That said, could you
clarify for me a something
about Merit Badges…?
If a requirement, for instance,
says, "visit a…”
or “report on what you learned…”
does that mean the
Merit Badge Counselor
must attend with the
Scout, or
could
a requirement
like that
be fulfilled by the Scout attending with a group of
other
Scouts
or as a family outing?
The
troop
my son joined
is a great troop and all the boys who
just crossed over
are well on their way to earning Tenderfoot.
My guy's been having fun and didn't even realize until the last meeting
that he only needed
three
more requirements to earn Tenderfoot!
(New Scout Mom)
When you get it that Boy Scouts isn't "Webelos 3,"
you're on your way to being the best kind of parent a Scout can have! I'm delighted to learn that your
son's doing well and is completing requirements to advance to his first
rank and beyond. As you review requirements
for rank advancement, be sure to let
him
tell
you,
and not the other way around!
This is the time for you to sit in the back of the Scouting "car" while
your son does the driving.
Merit badges are
available to be worked on and earned at any time (that is, there are no
age, size, rank, or other restrictions on merit badges—any Scout can
earn any merit badge any time he chooses). After your son decides what
merit badge he’d like to earn, his Merit Badge Counselor will meet with
him and they’ll discuss how he’ll go about completing the
requirements. With specific regard to
field trips and such, the Scout is expected to take the initiative for
himself. Unlike den outings, Merit
Badge Counselors almost never accompany the Scout on field trips, visits
to locales, events, designated buildings, etc.
The Scout will do this on his own, usually with a Scout buddy. Merit
badges aren't anything
parents
need to fret about, or consider "helping"
their
son with... He'll do just fine by himself, and your role 99.9% of the
time will simply be to get him to his Merit Badge Counselor's home, and
back again.
Dear
Andy,
Does a Life Scout meet
the requirement of being active,
who
rarely comes to troop meetings and hasn't been on a
campout
in 16 months? (Name & Council Withheld)
OK, let’s start here:
How long has he been a Life Scout? Next,
in the past 16 months, how
many merit badges has he earned,
and has he done an Eagle project?
Finally, what leadership position has he held for a minimum of 6 months
since becoming a Life Scout?
He earned Life rank
two years and two months ago. He’s earned no merit
badges since then, and he’s scheduled to start his Eagle project in
about two weeks. He was Quartermaster “Mentor”—a
Scoutmaster-assigned leadership project—for a year and three months
after becoming a Life Scout.
OK, this is a soluble situation... It
begins with this Scout having served actively in his troop, while a Life
Scout, for a period of 15 months while carrying out
that Scoutmaster-assigned troop leadership project. This means that
"active for 6 months since becoming a Life Scout" is now an academic
discussion: It was accomplished a year ago. Moreover, since this Scout
will need to earn the balance of the merit badges required and also
carry out his Eagle
project, including
recruiting
and managing his
helpers, he'll be devoting a lot more time
to Scouting that may be immediately evident.
In short, "active" is a non-issue right now and will remain a non-issue
in the future.
The best support you can provide this young man is to encourage his
planning out which merit badges he'll complete before the summer, which
he'll work to complete during the summer, and what "strays" he'll finish
off in the early fall. You can also provide guidance and support to him
as he carries out his service project in such a way that it will be
accepted by his board of review for Eagle.
We're here to guide young
men to success. We're not here to stick
monkey wrenches in their advancement gear
works. I'm sure you and the other adult volunteers associated with the
troop see the wisdom of success based on personal initiative!
Dear Andy,
Does
a
chartered
organization that
sponsors a
Cub
Scout pack have the right to keep that
same
number so
that
if one day it wants to
start a
Boy
Scout troop,
it could
have the same number as the pack? (Mark
Fury,
Istrouma Area Council, LA)
While it's not mandatory that a unit
number be held in reserve, it's certainly a fine courtesy that can be
extended by the council (usually the registrar), so have a chat
(in-person; no email) and ask for it!
Hi Andy,
We’ve just started a
co-ed
Sea Scout
ship.
On our first at-sea
trip,
we had the mother of a girl ship member along as her
supervisor,
plus the girl’s father
and
younger brother.
Now I’m all
in favor of the family going along on trips (it pretty much looks like
this
will be
the norm from here on out), but I
have some questions...
First, from a liability standpoint, should these parents be registered
as
“Scouting
Parents”?
If so, should they
be required to take any of the training that
registered leaders need to take? Further, if
these parents
aren’t going to become
registered
volunteers,
and/or
they don’t
need to or wish to take any training, and the family
comes on our ship’s trips
so
that
the mother can act as the female supervisor for
their daughter, do they need to sign a waiver that
releases the BSA, the ship, and us volunteers with the ship from
liability, and, if so,
what form
do they use? Also, what’s the BSA
policy on taking these
youth out of school to
attend our trips?
I welcome family participation, and we need the mother
for our co-ed group. At this point,
the mother and father aren’t
going to sign up to be registered
volunteers,
and the younger brother can’t
be left at home while
the parents go on these outings.
What do we do here? (Name & Council
Withheld)
To volunteer in the newest BSA
unit-level position—“ScoutParent Unit
Coordinator”—is
to take on some major responsibilities, including “Host an activity or a pool party for the
ship, go on a trip with the ship as an adult chaperone, be a consultant
on a career or hobby by teaching the skills of your trade, be one of the
key adult leaders involved with the ship, offer your property, business,
etc. for activities, assist with unit fund-raising, support
your Sea Scout about their program and provide guidance and
participation with them on meetings and events projects, encourage other
youth to invite their friends to join the program and help with sign-ups, attend
and help provide support to annual or regular parent involvement night
events, offer your talents and other
organization resources in support of the program,
be one of the key adult leaders involved with the ship, help collect a
Program Capability Inventory or Talent Survey from all families and
other community resources in support of the program, encourage and
support youth in leadership and mentoring, assist with transportation on
activities or meetings.” I certainly would encourage at least one of
these parents to get involved in a more formal and regular basis than
merely monitoring their daughter and tending to their under-age (for Sea
Scouting) son.
However, beyond this, there's
a fundamental issue you'll need to come to terms with, and when you do,
everything else that flows out of it will be crystal clear:
What kind of youth program do you wish to deliver?
You see, if you wish to deliver the
Sea Scouting program
as written,
then you'll need to make some important decisions about families such as
the one you’ve described.
That's because Sea Scouting is a
youth
program; it's not a "family" program.
In fact, I'm going to challenge you here:
Read any issue of the
Sea Scout Manual or the
Handbook for Skippers that's been written in the past 98 years
and find the phrase, "...the Sea Scout and his/her
parent/father/mother..." The bottom line is that
you won't. Sea Scouting isn't a "Dad
n' Lad" program; it's not a "Mom n' Me" program—It's
a youth program in which the young people interact, learn from, and have
fun and adventures with and among themselves, under the quiet and
unobtrusive guidance of their Skipper.
If Sea Scouting had been
intended to be a family program, then the manuals and handbooks would
have been written that way.
But they weren't, and that's not by accident.
Sea Scouting's goal is to
encourage and
instill personal competence, personal accomplishment,
independence, and inter-dependence among young people,
by creating an environment in which young people are responsible for and
to themselves; its purpose is not to "strengthen family ties" by "doing
things together as families." (And it’s certainly not intended
“for the whole family, regardless of age.”)
The
Sea Scout Manual doesn't have a single sentence in it
about "...you and your parent..."
The Handbook for Skippers doesn't have a single sentence in it
about "...the Sea Scouts and their parents..."
This is absolutely deliberate.
It is also not to be meddled with.
Meddle with this one and you may have a fine program for youth and their
parents; you simply won't have Sea Scouting.
This isn't about my "opinion"—My
only "opinion" is that we need to strive to understand the principles
underpinning all Scouting programs and then make the conscious decision
to deliver the Scouting program we've volunteered to deliver as it's
written and designed to be delivered.
Once you've done this, you'll know exactly what decisions you'll need to
make.
Thanks
for the advice.
It’s
funny that just the other day a fellow Scouter told me about a Camporee
at which some of the parents
were upset with him
because he didn’t
have
“family activities.”
His response to these parents was straightforward: This is
a
Boy Scout camping
experience; not a family camp-out.
I
think I need to
get the mother to register as
a Mate,
so she can accompany the daughter
and
additional girls that will join as the ship’s membership
grows, with the understanding that she’ll need to take training, and I need to tell the father
the same
thing. Then, the parents need to figure out what to do with the
younger
brother (e.g., get a sitter)
if both
of them plan to attend the same trip.
Please let me know if I’m
on the right track here,
because, if I am,
I’ll need to talk to the
district and the
council
folks to get this nipped in the bud
up front.
Yes, you're on the right track, with a possible couple of
tweaks here...
Are you sure, for instance, that you want
this particular woman to register?
Perhaps some other female parent might be better suited to the task of
registering as Mate and taking SSOST?
After all, didn't this woman already state that she's not interested in
registering, etc.?
Having someone else would also mean that
the father doesn't need to register and take SSOST, which means that the
younger brother definitely stays home.
Now it may turn out that these parents attempt the ploy of
demanding that the brother tag along, "or we won't be going and we'll
withhold our daughter." If they play this card,
simply tell them that it's their choice, as parents, to encourage or
deny their daughter, and if they choose to keep her from participating,
well, that's the end of the story, because you're not going to submit to
threats.
Hang in there—
You're getting it right!
OK, one last
question on this issue…
If the Sea Scout
ship
we’re
on has a female adult
leader, I
can use her and not the mother, yes? I’m thinking that
the mother and father
can help transport the Sea Scouts
to the
ship,
but unless they’re registered and trained, they can’t
board or go on the cruise. Is this OK to do?
Yes, all you need is a registered female leader and all
girl
Sea
Scouts are covered! With a registered-and-trained
adult
female leader on board, you can definitely
tell all non-registered parents that, until further notice, they're
landlubbers. Parents who help drive the
ship's youth
members to and from the launch-point are necessary, of course,
unless you have access to a multi-seat van of some sort, but their
responsibilities stop at dockside.
Fair winds and following seas --
Dear Andy,
I’m
a parent with a
son
very active in
Scouts
who’s repeating a grade, so he’ll
no longer meet age or grade requirements. What happens now? Some say
better to let him move on than
to hold him back,
because if he’s made to
repeat requirements, he may lose
interest and drop out.
Others
say he’s stuck,
because he can’t re-earn a rank,
and at the same time he can’t move on.
He loves
Cubs, and this would tear him apart. The
Cubmaster says
to
let him move on,
but he, himself, is stepping down,
and I don’t know what the next
Cubmaster might say. Will this catch up with him if
I leave it alone and let him ride,
as the
Cubmaster said?
I’m
totally lost here. Do you have
any suggestions? (Cub Scout Mom)
It's going to be OK... Just tell me
what he is right now... Tiger? Wolf? Bear? Webelos I?
He’s
currently a
Wolf
and 8 years old. He’s almost finished repeating first grade. But,
to go to
Bear,
he’ll still be
8, not 9, and he’ll
be starting
second
grade.
Keep him moving forward in Cub Scouts... Bear is the next stop,
beginning with the end of this school year.
Cub Scouting levels (i.e., Tiger, Wolf, Bear, and so on) are designed to
be age-specific, so he needs to be doing things soon at the Bear level,
because Wolf stuff would be no challenge (besides, he's already done
this, so a repeat would bore him to distraction!). Just have a
conversation with his Den Leader, so that he or she knows he'll be
sticking with his same den in the fall and beyond.
Dear Andy,
I'm sure there are background
checks
for registering adult volunteers, but
does that include background checks of parents,
also? How can someone be in charge of children when
they, themselves, have had their own taken away from them by the state
for neglect as well as drug use?
Is it okayed with the other parents
of
Scouts? (Name
& Council Withheld)
The BSA criminal background checks are done for all
registering
adult
volunteers who become members of the BSA through their packs, troops,
teams, crews, or district or councils, or as merit badge counselors.
Since the BSA does not collect information on adults who do not fill out
and turn in an application, such as parents who help out unofficially
from time to time, there's obviously no "paper trail" to follow for
background checking.
Dear Andy,
I’m
advancement coordinator
for our
troop.
We have a
Scout
who just successfully completed his Life rank board of review.
I didn’t
sit on that
particular review, but I was informed that
it was a tough decision on their part, with considerable
angst regarding the degree of active participation on the part of this
Scout.
The people on the review also had problems with this Scout’s inability
to recite the Scout Oath and Law correctly. I pointed out
to them
that making decisions as to what
they think
constitutes "active participation" is a particularly
dicey thing to do, so they moved on, although
somewhat begrudgingly.
Now the hard part... This
Scout's 18th birthday is
now upon him, less than two
months from the date of his Life
board of review.
He
lacks
six merit badges, three
of which are required for Eagle, and his leadership service
project. Plus, he’ll clearly
not meet the
six month participation and
leadership position tenure required
between Life and Eagle ranks, before
his 18th
birthday. His father is now aggressively seeking an extension
beyond
the
18th
birthday from our council,
and it’s probable that the troop committee will be asked
for a letter
showing
support of this request.
The
father’s rationale for requesting
the extension is
an
ADHD diagnosis.
Well over a year ago, at the request of this
father, I worked up a specific timeline for
this young man, specifying
the
deadline
dates
that he’d need to
meet in order to complete his advancement to Eagle before
his 18th birthday. Now, despite this, it seems
that it’s now
simply too late in the game,
despite the current
flurry of activity.
I’m
personally not in
favor
of deviating from BSA advancement
requirements, and I believe that, in
this case, such a deviation would be
a disservice to a long line of
Scouts
who have earned their ranks while staying within the
boundaries of BSA policy. Moreover, we have, and have had,
Scouts in the troop with
physical and/or
mental
challenges
equally if not more daunting who have asked for no
special favors of any kind. Nevertheless, I feel honor-bound to provide
objective input to the committee on this matter, so any insights you can
share would be much
appreciated. (Name & Council Withheld)
Question for you: Has the
ADHD "card" ever been played before?
If not, this might be an uphill climb for that family. According to the
BSA,
they do need to have written documentation
from a licensed medical professional, stating that this young man has a
permanent disability, in order to request special consideration. Since the disability is,
apparently, in the mental arena, an evaluation statement by a certified
educational administrator will likely also be required.
If they don't have these, the show's over.
If they do have them, they'll need to present them to the council
advancement committee for consideration (see page 13 of the BSA's
2010 Boy Scout Requirements book).
This, however, typically applies to the ranks below Star; not to Star,
Life, or Eagle. If they've never done this
before, in the past seven years, the council advancement committee may
take this into consideration.
At any rate, the full procedure is described in the book I mentioned.
In this regard, it does not seem necessary for the troop committee to
take a position one way or the other. This
is a council-level decision.
As for his board of review for Life, that's water
under the bridge... While we could spend a lot of time talking about it
(it sure
sounds like it
was a far cry from
ideal—on everyone’s part!),
that would accomplish little.
My personal recommendation for the future is that you,
as advancement coordinator for the troop, hand-pick board of review
members, selecting only those who understand what the role of the review
actually is and who follow it, meanwhile training or re-training others
on the troop committee so that they get it right next time.
I also think that you need to be chairing the reviews for a while, until
you get some folks better educated...
To return to the original subject for
a moment more, neither you nor the troop committee nor the Scoutmaster
is obliged to take a position one way or the other regarding this Scout,
except to observe that while in the troop he successfully advanced to
the rank of Life Scout by the time he was 17 years, 10 months old.
Dear Andy,
I’ve
looked through many of your past columns for a reference that deals with
this particular issue, but I wasn’t quite able to find any… Specifically
I pointed out to our committee members - this from the
2010 Boy Scout Requirements book:
“The Scout is not required to attend any
certain percentage of activities or outings. However, unit leaders must
ensure that he is fulfilling the obligations of his assigned leadership
position. If he is not, then they should remove the Scout from that
position."
Based on this statement, I noted that it’s clear that a troop cannot
deny a Scout rank advancement based on attendance.
The response to this, from a
committee member, was: “Please remember that all units
have the ability to set the standard they expect for their individual
Scouts—so
long as this is
in writing and presented to each of the
Scouts.
This
goes for all aspects of expectations, conduct, and required elements
for advancement.
We have such a document,
which has been in effect for a number of
years now.
As
council has stated and
agrees to: Any
unit has the right to determine their own requirements and
expectations for their
Scouts, as long as these are reasonable, enforceable, and
uniform for all Scouts.”
My son is in this troop and they do
have a document—it’s been in existence for about seven years—that states
the exact
attendance
percentages
required of the
Scout, in order to advance in
rank. I know
that BSA national standards do not permit this, but this
man has indicated that
“council”
has
allowed this.
He’s a long-time
member of this troop
and he
certainly seems more knowledgeable about
such
issues than I, but
where would I look to
find out what rules
“council”
can impose, superseding BSA national standards,
and by what authority they can override national policies?
You’ve pointed out in various columns
that these violations are
wrong, but could you please give me a reference to cite…some
official rule that says
that BSA national
standards or
policies
can’t be violated,
altered, or circumvented?
Your fundamental question's
actually an easy one to answer.
Page 13 of the BSA's
Boy Scout Requirements
book (No. 34765) states clearly: "No council, district, unit, or
individual has the authority to add to, or to subtract from, any
advancement requirements."
But here's the unfortunate part: Any individual or group of individuals
who needs to be shown this, in order for them to understand that we just
don't have the right to make stuff up when it should be a plain as the
nose on their face that national standards can't be superseded for any
reason, are pretty hopeless…to the point where I'd probably have to say
that your son and his friends are in the wrong troop and need to get out
and find a troop that gets what they're supposed to be doing right.
If the people in your son's present troop need to be "convinced" of
something so seminal as this, it's already too late.
You see, the only purpose to
being a Scouting volunteer is to help boys and young men
succeed; it's not to find ways
for them to fail.
When adults create ways for boys to fail, they're, in effect,
anti-Scouting in principle. But to change this "from
within" is unlikely, because the most likely situation is that
calcification has set in and the only way to effect change is not by
convincing but by removal.
The
Scoutmaster Handbook
tells us that the Scoutmaster's single-most important responsibility is
to train the youth leaders of the troop, so that they can run their own
troop. This is classic "OJT," with course
adjustments all along the way, so that, in the end, all Scouts succeed.
To wait in ambush at the end of the trail, in order to
tell a Scout that, well, he just hasn't lived up to expectations, is
about as anti-Scouting in principle
and spirit
as one can get.
So, my personal suggestion here is
to consider ending your quest to shovel water upstream with a pitchfork
and, with a few other parents, go out and visit other nearby troops,
till you find one that gets it right, and then transfer your sons into
that troop as fast as you can!
The people associated with the troop your son’s in at the moment should
be—as B-P himself observed—taken out and shot.
Hello Andy,
I’m
having a problem trying to figure out what to do about our town’s troop. I’m
Committee
Chair of the
“feeder”
pack and my son will be going to this troop in two years.
We’ve recently
sent
five of our Webelos Scouts
to this troop and
all five have
either transferred
to another troop or dropped out of Scouts entirely,
because they
were made to feel
like
“outsiders.”
It seems that,
on Webelos visits,
the troop just
plays games for
about
45 minutes and
then does “Scouting things” for maybe
about 20 minutes or so (all
was
the same in the
three visits I've
made). So how
do we help the troop become a troop that we’d
be proud to send our
boys
to and know they’ll
strive for great things? I
did pose this same question to our District Executive, but he just said
that it’ll probably take a while to work itself out.
Meanwhile, our chartered organization doesn’t take
much interest in either our pack or the troop they sponsor, too. (Eric Scarberry,
Simon
Kenton Council,
OH)
The first thing we need to
keep in mind is that D.E.'s are virtually powerless when it comes to the
quality of the Scouting program a unit delivers—so
don't blame your D.E. for giving the appearance of shirking what he
can't control! Responsibility for program
quality ultimately lies with the chartered organization—that's
where the buck stops—and so if they're really
not much involved, this may be an insoluble situation.
However, since you have two years before your own decision needs to be
made, you may want to consider getting yourself into the position of
Chartered Organization Representative for
both
units—the pack
and the troop.
If you can do this, then you're in control of all adult volunteers. As
CR, you can, for instance, insist that they all take
training for their positions (and if they don't, you can replace them
with absolute impunity). You can insist that the
troop follow The Patrol Method to the letter, and that they use the
Troop Meeting Plan—developed and run by the
Patrol Leaders Council—for
all troop meetings. You can do these things
not by being "The Big Cheese" but by applying diplomatically gentle
pressure...relentlessly.
This way, in two years' time or, ideally, a lot less, this becomes a
model troop that any boy would be excited to join and have fun in!
Understand this very
clearly: You absolutely cannot change a corrupted organization "from
within"—The only way to change it is from the
top. So make your decisions
ruthlessly, but carry them out
compassionately.
Dear Andy,
My son applied to his
Scoutmaster and troop committee for the rank of Eagle
Scout, having met all the requirements including completing his
leadership service project.
The
Scoutmaster refused to process
his application,
stating that my son didn’t
meet the troop’s 75% attendance requirement, and he didn’t
meet the leadership requirements that the Scoutmaster wanted. When
my son
appealed this
decision
with
the council,
the
Scoutmaster and troop
advancement chair
de-registered him, his brother,
and me, and of course we
appealed these actions as well. The council
advancement committee stated that neither the
troop’s attendance requirement
nor its additional
leadership requirements met with
BSA
national
policy, and that my son had, in fact,
exceeded the Eagle Scout
rank
requirements, granting his appeal and advancing
him to the rank of Eagle Scout
in a
subsequent
council-level
board of review.
Unfortunately, however, the two troop leaders
now
refuse to recognize
my son’s legitimate
advancement to
the rank of
Eagle Scout and
will not
provide him a court of honor. He’s
now 18 years old. He
received his Eagle Scout documents, badge, and medal in the mail.
I’m seeking your advice and closure.
(Martin Jacobson)
Congratulations to
your Eagle Scout son!
There's absolutely nothing
whatsoever prohibiting you from celebrating his achievement.
Schedule a date and time, choose a location (your home, church, or other
place large enough to hold a crowd), and invite the Chair of the Council
Advancement Committee and the members of your son’s
board of review to come and enjoy the festivities. In fact, you may even wish to ask the
chair to make the actual presentation.
Invite your son’s
best friends from the troop, any families
that you're close with, neighbors, his teachers and principal, local
dignitaries, and your own Scouting friends.
Use official Eagle Scout invitations (available at your local Scout shop
or online at
www.Scoutstuff.org),
order a cake, and have a blast!
As far as those two jerks are concerned forget 'em. They don't deserve any consideration
beyond remembering that throughout our lives we're going to run into
jerks (God must love jerks—He
sure made
a lot
of 'em!).
Here's the important thing:
Your son
refused to be walked on, because he refused to lie down like a door
mat! Instead, he took action and as a result the right outcome
prevailed!
Hats off to all!
Now go have the party you all deserve!
Happy Scouting!
|
Got a
question? Have an idea? Send it to
AskAndyBSA@yahoo.com. (Please include your POSITION
and COUNCIL NAME or TOWN & STATE)
(May 10, 2010 – Copyright © Andy McCommish 2010) |
|
|
Letters to AskAndy may be published at the discretion of
the columnist and the editor. If you
prefer to have your name or affiliation withheld from
publication, please advise in your letter..